Home › Compare
Quince
Pavoi
The Verdict
Quince and Pavoi are tied at 78 in our JewelryScore system, but Quince wins on the strength of solid 14K gold construction versus Pavoi's gold-plated pieces. Both deliver exceptional value in the budget tier, but Quince's genuine gold means your jewelry won't eventually wear through to the base metal.
Head-to-Head Breakdown
| Dimension | Quince | Pavoi |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Score | 78/100 | 78/100 |
| Quality | 32/40 | 32/40 |
| Value | 30/35 | 30/35 |
| Style | 16/25 | 16/25 |
| Price Range | $20–$100 | $12–$50 |
| Materials | Solid 14K Gold, Sterling Silver | 14K Gold Plated Sterling Silver |
| Longevity | Lifetime (solid gold) | 12-18 months (plated) |
| Price Entry Point | $20 | $12 |
What Customers Say
Quince
Quince customers are impressed by receiving solid 14K gold at budget-friendly prices. The dominant theme is disbelief at the value — verified gold content at prices typically reserved for plated jewelry. Design criticism is common, with many noting the extremely minimalist aesthetic.
Pavoi
Pavoi customers praise durability that exceeds expectations for the price point. Many report pieces lasting over a year without tarnishing. The Amazon-centric buying experience earns praise for convenience, though some note clasp quality issues on select pieces.
Category-by-Category
Go with Quince. Solid 14K gold studs at $60 will outlast Pavoi's plated versions indefinitely — a better long-term investment.
Go with Pavoi. Pavoi's lower price point and multi-piece sets (like the 6-pair CZ studs for $18) make it the better value for gifting.
Go with Quince. For pieces you'll wear daily, solid gold resists tarnishing permanently — plated pieces will eventually show wear.
Go with Pavoi. Pavoi's Amazon presence means Prime shipping, easy returns, and a massive review base to reference before buying.
Key Data Points
Independent testing confirmed Quince's 14K gold purity matches advertised specifications in 98% of sampled pieces, while Pavoi's gold plating averages 2.5 microns thick.
Pavoi maintains a 4.3/5 rating across 15,000+ Amazon reviews, while Quince has 4.3/5 across 2,400+ Trustpilot reviews — both reflecting consistent customer satisfaction.
Quince's solid 14K gold pieces are priced under $100, making them the most affordable genuine gold jewelry in our database — Pavoi achieves even lower prices through gold plating over sterling silver.
Final Verdict
This is the budget gold jewelry showdown, but these two brands take fundamentally different approaches to affordability. Quince uses solid 14K gold and keeps prices low through supply chain efficiency. Pavoi uses gold plating over sterling silver to hit even lower price points. Both work — but for different reasons.
Solid Gold vs. Gold Plated
The critical distinction is materials. Quince’s $60 gold studs are solid 14K gold — they’ll never tarnish, never wear through, and will look the same in 10 years. Pavoi’s $22 gold-plated huggie hoops look identical on day one but will eventually show wear after 12-18 months of daily use. This is the fundamental trade-off: pay more for permanent or pay less and replace.
Who Should Buy Which
Pavoi is the smarter choice if you want variety, like to rotate your jewelry frequently, or are buying gifts where the look matters more than longevity. Their Amazon presence makes buying frictionless, and the sub-$30 prices mean you can build a collection without commitment.
Quince is the better investment if you want a few core pieces that last forever. Spending $60-85 on solid gold basics that never need replacing is genuinely more cost-effective than buying plated pieces every year.
The Bottom Line
We give Quince the edge because solid gold at these prices is genuinely remarkable. But Pavoi is not the lesser choice — it’s the different choice, and for many buyers, it’s the right one.