Home › Compare
Mint & Lily
Quince
The Verdict
Mint & Lily dominates this comparison with a 93 vs 78 JewelryScore lead over Quince. While Quince offers solid 14K gold at remarkable prices, Mint & Lily delivers superior quality (38 vs 32), significantly better value (33 vs 30), and a personalization experience that Quince simply doesn't offer. For anyone seeking customized, meaningful jewelry on a budget, Mint & Lily is the clear winner.
Head-to-Head Breakdown
| Dimension | Mint & Lily | Quince |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Score | 93/100 | 78/100 |
| Quality | 38/40 | 32/40 |
| Value | 33/35 | 30/35 |
| Style | 20/25 | 16/25 |
| Price Range | $35–$90 | $20–$100 |
| Personalization | Name necklaces, engraving, birthstones, fonts | None available |
| Materials | Sterling Silver, 18K Gold Plated | Solid 14K Gold, Sterling Silver |
| Customer Service | 97% response rate, praised for going above and beyond | Good, responsive |
What Customers Say
Mint & Lily
Mint & Lily customers are overwhelmingly positive about the personalization quality, gift-giving experience, and customer service. The dominant theme across 33,000+ reviews is that pieces exceed expectations for the price — particularly name necklaces and birthstone jewelry that feel special and personal.
Quince
Quince customers appreciate the transparency and genuine gold at budget prices. Sentiment is positive but often notes the extremely basic, minimalist designs. Customers value the materials but wish for more variety, personalization options, and distinctive styling.
Category-by-Category
Go with Mint & Lily. Quince offers zero personalization — Mint & Lily is the undisputed leader with name necklaces, birthstones, and custom engraving in multiple fonts.
Go with Mint & Lily. Mint & Lily's Classic Name Necklace at $49.90 is one of the best-reviewed personalized pieces in the market — Quince has no competing product.
Go with Quince. For simple, unadorned solid 14K gold basics like studs and thin bands, Quince's genuine gold at $60-85 is unbeatable.
Go with Mint & Lily. Birthstone options, custom engraving, and beautiful packaging make Mint & Lily the complete gift-giving experience at accessible prices.
Go with Quince. For plain chains, bands, and studs worn daily, Quince's solid gold construction will outlast plated alternatives.
Key Data Points
Mint & Lily maintains a 4.5/5 TrustScore across 33,000+ reviews with a 94% positive sentiment rate for long-term quality — significantly more data than Quince's 2,400+ reviews.
Mint & Lily responds to 97% of negative reviews within 48 hours, demonstrating a customer service commitment that goes well beyond the industry norm.
Quince's solid 14K gold at under $100 is remarkable for materials, but Mint & Lily's 38/40 quality score — the highest in our database — shows that craftsmanship and personalization quality can outweigh raw material purity.
Final Verdict
This comparison highlights two very different philosophies of budget jewelry. Quince focuses on material purity — genuine solid gold at the lowest possible price. Mint & Lily focuses on the complete experience — personalization, craftsmanship, packaging, and customer service that transforms affordable jewelry into something that feels genuinely special.
The Personalization Advantage
Mint & Lily’s defining strength is something Quince doesn’t even attempt: personalization. Name necklaces, custom engraving, birthstone settings, multiple font choices — these options transform a piece of jewelry from an accessory into a meaningful gift. For birthdays, anniversaries, Mother’s Day, or any occasion where sentiment matters, Mint & Lily delivers an experience that generic basics simply can’t match.
Quality That Speaks for Itself
Mint & Lily’s 38/40 quality score is the highest in our entire database, reflecting exceptional craftsmanship across thousands of personalized pieces. Each item is made to order with careful attention to engraving precision, stone setting, and finishing. Quince’s quality is solid for basic pieces, but Mint & Lily’s ability to maintain this standard across customized, made-to-order jewelry is genuinely impressive.
The Materials Trade-off
Quince’s one clear advantage is solid 14K gold construction — pieces that will never tarnish or wear through. Mint & Lily uses sterling silver and 18K gold plating, which requires more care over time. For buyers who prioritize material purity above all else, Quince delivers. But for the majority of shoppers — especially those buying gifts or wanting something personal and unique — Mint & Lily’s superior quality, value, and customer experience make it the better choice by a significant margin.