Home › Compare
Mint & Lily
Gorjana
The Verdict
Mint & Lily wins this head-to-head with a JewelryScore of 93 vs 78, outperforming Gorjana in Quality (38 vs 32) and Value (33 vs 24). Gorjana leads in style and trend alignment, but the quality-per-dollar gap is significant.
Head-to-Head Breakdown
| Dimension | Mint & Lily | Gorjana |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Score | 93/100 | 78/100 |
| Quality | 38/40 | 32/40 |
| Value | 33/35 | 24/35 |
| Style | 20/25 | 22/25 |
| Price Range | $35–$90 | $40–$150 |
| Tarnish Rate | 3% | 11% |
| Shipping Speed | 2–3 weeks (custom) | 5–7 days |
| Return Policy | 30 days | 30 days |
What Customers Say
Mint & Lily
Customers consistently praise Mint & Lily's durability and value, with the most common theme being pieces that hold up beautifully over months of daily wear. The 94% positive sentiment rate is the highest in our database.
Gorjana
Gorjana customers love the brand's aesthetic and layering potential, but price sensitivity is a recurring theme. The design quality is praised while the materials-to-price ratio is questioned.
Category-by-Category
Go with Mint & Lily. Superior engraving quality at half the price.
Go with Gorjana. More initial styles and better layering ecosystem.
Go with Mint & Lily. Better durability scores and more customization options.
Go with Gorjana. Faster shipping and more trend-forward designs for daily rotation.
Key Data Points
In our head-to-head comparison, Mint & Lily scored 93/100 vs Gorjana's 78/100, with the biggest gap in Value (33/35 vs 24/35).
Mint & Lily's tarnish complaint rate of 3% is 73% lower than Gorjana's 11%, reflecting a significant durability advantage.
Gorjana charges an average of 45% more than Mint & Lily for comparable personalized pieces, with quality scores 6 points lower.
Final Verdict
This comparison isn’t close on the numbers: Mint & Lily wins by 13 points. The gap is driven almost entirely by value — Mint & Lily delivers similar or better quality at significantly lower prices.
Where Gorjana makes sense is for buyers who prioritize style and trend alignment over value. Gorjana’s design language is genuinely distinctive, and the layering ecosystem is well-executed. But for personalized jewelry, the data strongly favors Mint & Lily.