Home › Compare
Mint & Lily
Ana Luisa
The Verdict
Mint & Lily leads this matchup 93 to 81, with advantages in quality and customization options. Ana Luisa counters with strong sustainability credentials and competitive pricing as the only carbon-neutral brand in our database.
Head-to-Head Breakdown
| Dimension | Mint & Lily | Ana Luisa |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Score | 93/100 | 81/100 |
| Quality | 38/40 | 32/40 |
| Value | 33/35 | 30/35 |
| Style | 20/25 | 19/25 |
| Price Range | $35–$90 | $30–$85 |
| Tarnish Rate | 3% | 7% |
| Sustainability | Standard | Carbon-neutral, recycled metals |
What Customers Say
Mint & Lily
Mint & Lily customers praise durability and customization options. The 94% positive sentiment rate reflects a brand that consistently exceeds expectations at its price point.
Ana Luisa
Ana Luisa customers value the sustainability mission and find quality above expectations for the price. The brand is praised as 'the best value in affordable jewelry' by multiple reviewers.
Category-by-Category
Go with Mint & Lily. More font options, better engraving quality, wider metal selection.
Go with Ana Luisa. Clean designs purpose-built for daily wear at slightly lower prices.
Go with Ana Luisa. Only carbon-neutral brand in our database with full sustainability credentials.
Key Data Points
Mint & Lily outscores Ana Luisa 93 to 81, with the biggest gap in Quality (38/40 vs 32/40) — a 6-point difference driven by superior durability metrics.
Ana Luisa's carbon-neutral certification makes it the top choice for the 34% of jewelry buyers who cite sustainability as a purchase factor.
Both brands offer competitive pricing under $90, but Mint & Lily's tarnish rate of 3% vs Ana Luisa's 7% gives it a significant edge in long-term wearability.
Final Verdict
Both brands serve the affordable jewelry market well, but Mint & Lily’s quality edge is clear in the data. The 6-point quality gap and less than half the tarnish rate give Mint & Lily a meaningful durability advantage.
Where Ana Luisa wins definitively is sustainability. For eco-conscious buyers, the carbon-neutral certification is a genuine differentiator that no other brand in our database can match. If sustainability is a top priority, Ana Luisa is the data-backed choice.