Home › Compare
Blue Nile
Brilliant Earth
The Verdict
Blue Nile and Brilliant Earth are tied at 82 in our JewelryScore system, but Blue Nile takes the win on superior value (30 vs 26). Brilliant Earth leads in quality (33 vs 32) and style (23 vs 20), but its 15-20% price premium and inconsistent post-sale service tip the balance toward Blue Nile for most diamond shoppers.
Head-to-Head Breakdown
| Dimension | Blue Nile | Brilliant Earth |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Score | 82/100 | 82/100 |
| Quality | 32/40 | 33/40 |
| Value | 30/35 | 26/35 |
| Style | 20/25 | 23/25 |
| Price Range | $200–$2,000 | $200–$5,000+ |
| Materials | 14K/18K Gold, Platinum, GIA Diamonds | Recycled 18K Gold, Recycled Platinum, Lab & Natural Diamonds |
| Ethical Sourcing | GIA certification, standard sourcing | Industry-leading ethical sourcing |
| Customer Service | Strong, consistent | Mixed, inconsistent post-sale |
What Customers Say
Blue Nile
Blue Nile customers consistently praise the transparent pricing, GIA certification detail, and competitive value. The most common positive theme is saving thousands compared to local jewelers on engagement rings. Design criticism is frequent — selections are seen as conservative but reliable.
Brilliant Earth
Brilliant Earth customers love the ethical mission and customization options, with showroom experiences earning particular praise. Post-sale frustrations include shipping delays on custom orders and inconsistent customer service responsiveness, tempering otherwise strong product satisfaction.
Category-by-Category
Go with Blue Nile. 30-40% savings over traditional retail with GIA-certified diamonds and reliable service make Blue Nile the value leader.
Go with Brilliant Earth. Brilliant Earth pioneered ethical lab-grown diamonds with extensive customization options and design flexibility.
Go with Blue Nile. Tennis bracelets, solitaire pendants, and timeless pieces at transparent prices without ethical premiums.
Go with Brilliant Earth. Recycled metals, ethical sourcing transparency, and lab-grown options make it the clear choice for sustainability-focused buyers.
Go with Blue Nile. Comprehensive GIA certification details, 360-degree diamond viewers, and educational resources set the industry standard.
Key Data Points
Blue Nile reports average savings of 30-40% compared to traditional brick-and-mortar jewelers, while Brilliant Earth commands a 15-20% premium over competitors like Blue Nile for equivalent diamonds.
Brilliant Earth maintains a 4.1/5 TrustScore with 60% five-star ratings, but 12% of custom orders exceed quoted delivery timelines according to customer feedback.
Blue Nile has sold over 500,000 GIA-certified diamonds annually, establishing it as the most trusted online diamond retailer by volume.
Final Verdict
This is the defining matchup for online diamond shoppers. Both Blue Nile and Brilliant Earth have transformed how people buy fine jewelry, but they’ve taken different paths — Blue Nile prioritizing value and simplicity, Brilliant Earth emphasizing ethics and design.
The Value vs. Ethics Trade-off
The core difference comes down to what you’re willing to pay for. Blue Nile offers the lowest prices on GIA-certified diamonds with transparent, no-nonsense pricing. Brilliant Earth charges a 15-20% premium for ethically sourced materials, recycled metals, and a broader design catalog. Whether that premium is worth it depends entirely on your priorities.
The Service Gap
Blue Nile’s consistent customer service is a genuine advantage. Brilliant Earth’s pre-sale experience — especially in showrooms — is excellent, but 12% of custom orders exceeding delivery timelines creates real frustration during what should be an exciting purchase. For engagement rings, where timing matters, this inconsistency is particularly costly.
The Bottom Line
For pure diamond value and reliable service, Blue Nile is the smarter choice. For buyers who prioritize ethical sourcing and want more design options — and are willing to pay a premium for both — Brilliant Earth delivers a product worth the extra cost. Both earn B+ grades because they’re genuinely good at what they do.