Home › Brands › Studs › Birthstone Stud
Birthstone Stud
Last updated:
74 / 100
ProductScore
Materials: 14K gold-plated brass; synthetic birthstone; sold individually
View on Studs →The Verdict
Studs' Birthstone Stud earns a B- ProductScore of 74/100 — a fun, affordable personalized earring that punches above its price in style and presentation. The synthetic stones and plated construction limit longevity, but at $35 for a single stud, it delivers solid value for curated ear styling.
Score Breakdown
What Customers Say
Based on 2,100 mentions across social media and review platforms
Studs' Birthstone Studs are a TikTok favorite for curated ear styling. Gen Z reviewers love the personalization angle and the brand's approachable aesthetic. The main debate online centers on longevity — some report plating wear after 4-6 months of daily wear, while others have no issues with occasional use.
"Cute little stud! I got my birthstone (amethyst) and it's the perfect pop of color in my second piercing. Great packaging too."
Reddit r/jewelry
"At $35 for one earring you're not getting luxury, but the quality is fine for the price. I rotate mine so the plating has held up."
Google Reviews
"Bought birthstone studs for my whole friend group as holiday gifts. Everyone loved them. The presentation makes them feel special."
Trustpilot
"The gold plating started wearing off on the back after about 5 months of daily wear. The stone still looks fine though."
Reddit r/femalefashionadvice
"Love the concept and the branding. Studs makes earring shopping feel fun rather than intimidating. The stud itself is small but well-made."
Google Reviews
Pros & Cons
Strengths
- + Affordable entry point at $35 for personalized jewelry
- + 12 birthstone options cover every month with distinct colors
- + Small scale makes it perfect for second, third, or cartilage piercings
- + Thoughtful packaging elevates the gifting experience
- + Lightweight and comfortable for all-day wear
Trade-offs
- − Gold plating can wear off with daily use after 4-6 months
- − Sold individually — a pair costs $70, which shifts the value proposition
- − Synthetic stones rather than natural gemstones
- − Limited metal color options beyond yellow gold-tone
Specifications
| Metal | 14K gold-plated brass |
| Stone | Synthetic birthstone (12 options) |
| Size | 3mm stone setting |
| Backing | Flat back push-in post |
| Sold As | Individual (single earring) |
| Care | Remove before showering; store in included pouch |
Alternatives to Consider
Featured in Gift Guides
Best Jewelry Gifts for Daughter
Best earring gift — flat-back comfort design with her birth month stone
Best Jewelry Gifts Under $50
Best earring gift — flat-back comfort with birth month personalization
Best Personalized Jewelry Gifts Under $75
Best earring gift — comfortable flat-back design with birthstone personalization
Best Jewelry Under $100
Best earring — flat-back comfort design with birth month personalization
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Studs Birthstone Studs real gold?
Are Studs Birthstone Studs sold as a pair or individually?
How long does the gold plating last on Studs earrings?
Are the birthstones in Studs earrings real?
Full Review
Studs has turned earring shopping into a curated experience, and the Birthstone Stud is the personalization cornerstone of that strategy. At $35 for a single stud, it’s positioned squarely as an affordable way to add meaning and color to a curated ear.
Design & Craftsmanship
The Birthstone Stud is deliberately small — the 3mm synthetic stone is scaled for second and third piercings where delicate proportions matter. The flat-back push-in post is a smart choice: it sits flush against the earlobe, eliminates the butterfly-back snag risk, and is comfortable enough for side-sleepers.
Each of the 12 birthstone colors is well-saturated and consistent across units. While synthetic stones won’t impress a gemologist, they deliver the color pop that curated ear styling demands. The gold-plated brass setting is cleanly finished with no visible rough edges or excess material.
Value Proposition
At $35 for a single stud, the value equation depends entirely on how you use it. As an accent piece rotated with other earrings, it’s a reasonable purchase — the plating holds up well with occasional wear. As a daily-wear earring, the math gets harder: plating degradation within 6 months means an effective cost of $70/year to maintain the look, at which point solid gold options start entering the conversation.
The individual pricing is a double-edged sword. It enables mix-and-match creativity (a key part of Studs’ brand identity), but it also means a matching pair costs $70 — entering territory where competitors offer higher-quality materials.
The Wear Test
Occasional wearers (2-3 times per week) report the plating holding up well for 8+ months. Daily wearers see plating wear on the post and back of the setting within 4-6 months, though the front-facing stone setting tends to last longer. The flat-back post is universally praised for comfort.
Who Should Buy This
The Birthstone Stud is perfect for curated ear enthusiasts building a rotation of mix-and-match studs, gift-givers looking for a personalized present under $50, and anyone who wants a pop of color in their piercing lineup. If you need everyday durability, invest in solid gold.
