Studs Review
Last updated: · 80 reviews analyzed
The Verdict
Studs delivers affordable, trendy earrings averaging $40 with good initial quality and comfortable wear, but faces notable durability issues with tarnishing occurring within 6-12 months of daily wear. The brand excels at social media presence and piercing services but struggles with inconsistent customer service and long-term jewelry performance.
The Social Verdict
Based on analysis of 80+ reviews across Reddit, Trustpilot, Google Reviews, Exa Web Search
Customers consistently praise Studs for affordable pricing, comfortable daily wear, and extensive jewelry selection with strong social media appeal. However, a significant portion of reviews highlight durability concerns, particularly tarnishing of gold-plated pieces within a year and occasional allergic reactions. The piercing services receive positive feedback for cleanliness and professionalism, though some note limited piercing jewelry options and inconsistent customer service experiences.
"SUPER impressed with Studs. Really high quality products, beautiful packaging, super fast delivery"
— Thingtesting
"I got 4 piercings and bought 2 sets of gold plated earrings. Less than a year later, one set is completely tarnished"
— Thingtesting
"Such a reasonable price for great products! This is my favorite jewelry brand"
— Thingtesting
"The customer service experience is inconsistent and occasionally poor"
— Thingtesting
Pros & Cons
Strengths
- + Affordable pricing with pieces averaging $40, significantly cheaper than solid gold alternatives
- + Comfortable for daily wear with hypoallergenic materials and 24/7 wearability
- + Extensive jewelry selection with mix-and-match options and trendy designs
- + Professional piercing services using needles rather than guns with clean facilities
Trade-offs
- − Significant tarnishing issues with gold-plated jewelry occurring within 6-12 months
- − Inconsistent customer service experiences reported across multiple review platforms
- − Potential for allergic reactions despite hypoallergenic claims, particularly with nickel-sensitive users
Product Reviews
5 products reviewed
Ear Cuff
Earrings · 14K gold-plated brass
Studs' Ear Cuff earns a B ProductScore of 76/100 — the brand's best value play and a clever no-commitment way to try the curated ear trend. At $28, the plating concerns matter less for a piece designed to be rotated, and the no-piercing design opens the door for jewelry-curious newcomers.
Birthstone Stud
Earrings · 14K gold-plated brass
Studs' Birthstone Stud earns a B- ProductScore of 74/100 — a fun, affordable personalized earring that punches above its price in style and presentation. The synthetic stones and plated construction limit longevity, but at $35 for a single stud, it delivers solid value for curated ear styling.
Dome Stud
Earrings · 14K gold-plated brass
Studs' Dome Stud earns a B- ProductScore of 73/100 — a trendy sculptural stud that captures the dome jewelry wave at an accessible price. The gold-plated construction limits its lifespan, but the eye-catching shape and comfortable flat-back design make it a solid rotational piece.
Classic Huggie
Earrings · 14K gold-plated brass
Studs' Classic Huggie earns a B- ProductScore of 72/100 — a well-designed entry-level huggie hoop with Gen Z appeal and clever branding. The gold plating limits longevity compared to solid gold alternatives, but at $40 for a pair, it's a low-risk gateway into huggie hoops.
Tiny Initial Stud
Earrings · 14K gold-plated brass
Studs' Tiny Initial Stud earns a B- ProductScore of 70/100 — a charming personalized stud that nails the curated ear aesthetic but faces the same plating durability concerns as the rest of the lineup. At $35 per stud, the personalization premium is the main draw.
Key Data Points
Thingtesting analysis shows 83% of Studs reviewers would recommend the brand to friends, ranking it #2 in their jewelry category
Multiple customer reviews document gold-plated Studs earrings tarnishing completely within less than one year of regular wear
Studs piercing services are priced at $35 for one piercing or $50 for two, plus jewelry costs starting at $30
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Studs worth it?
Does Studs jewelry tarnish?
Are Studs piercings safe?
Studs is best understood as a piercing brand with a jewelry line, not the other way around. The B rating reflects solid execution within that niche — the piercing experience is genuinely excellent, and the earring designs are well-curated for the curated-ear trend.
For earring buyers seeking affordable, comfortable studs and huggies with a great in-store experience, Studs delivers. For jewelry beyond earrings, you’ll need to look elsewhere. The flat back design innovation is worth noting — it’s a genuine comfort improvement that the data validates.