Quince Review
Last updated: · 150 reviews analyzed
The Verdict
Quince delivers exceptional value with genuine 14K gold pieces under $100, backed by impressive supply chain transparency. While their minimalist aesthetic won't appeal to everyone, the quality-to-price ratio is outstanding for solid gold jewelry.
The Social Verdict
Based on analysis of 150+ reviews across Reddit, Trustpilot, Google Reviews, Exa Web Search
Customers consistently praise Quince's transparency and value proposition, with many impressed by receiving solid 14K gold at such accessible prices. Some critics note the extremely minimalist designs can feel generic, while others appreciate the timeless simplicity. The brand has built strong trust through their detailed sourcing information and consistent quality delivery.
"I was skeptical about $60 14K gold studs but these are legit! Had them tested and they're exactly as advertised. Quince's transparency about their supply chain is refreshing."
— Reddit r/jewelry
"Finally found a brand that doesn't markup jewelry 10x! The gold band I got is simple but well-made and I love knowing exactly where my money went."
— Trustpilot
"The quality is there but honestly the designs are so basic. I wish they had more interesting or unique pieces instead of just thin bands and tiny studs."
— Reddit r/femalefashionadvice
"Decent jewelry for the price point. Shipping was quick and packaging was nice. Nothing groundbreaking but solid basics."
— Google Reviews
Pros & Cons
Strengths
- + Exceptional transparency in pricing and supply chain sourcing
- + Genuine 14K solid gold pieces under $100 - rare in the market
- + Consistent quality control with proper hallmarking
- + Fast shipping and excellent customer service response times
Trade-offs
- − Very limited design variety - mostly basic, minimalist pieces
- − No customization or personalization options available
- − Smaller selection compared to other jewelry brands in this price range
Product Reviews
5 products reviewed
14K Gold Ball Stud Earrings
Earrings · 14K solid gold, butterfly backs
Quince's 14K Gold Ball Stud Earrings deliver exceptional value for solid gold jewelry at $60. While the 3mm size is quite petite and may not suit those wanting more statement pieces, they're perfect everyday staples with secure backing.
14K Gold Huggie Hoop Earrings
Earrings · Solid 14K gold with hinged closure mechanism
Quince's 14K Gold Huggie Hoops deliver solid construction and timeless style at an accessible price point. While the design is basic, the secure closure and genuine gold construction make them a reliable everyday staple.
18K Gold Vermeil Signet Ring
Rings · 18K gold vermeil over sterling silver base
Quince delivers a well-crafted signet ring that punches above its weight class with thick gold vermeil plating and classic styling. While it won't last as long as solid gold alternatives, it offers exceptional value for those wanting the signet ring look without the premium price.
14K Gold Thin Band Ring
Rings · 14K solid gold
Quince's 14K Gold Thin Band Ring delivers exceptional value for solid gold jewelry at this price point. While the ultra-thin design may be too delicate for some, it's perfect for stacking and everyday wear.
Sterling Silver Rope Chain Necklace
Necklaces · Solid sterling silver (.925)
Quince's Sterling Silver Rope Chain delivers solid quality at an impressive price point, making it an excellent entry-level piece for everyday wear. While the chain shows some minor quality inconsistencies typical of budget jewelry, it offers genuine sterling silver construction that punches above its weight class.
Key Data Points
Quince reports 92% customer satisfaction rate based on post-purchase surveys from Q3 2024
Independent testing confirmed 14K gold purity matches advertised specifications in 98% of sampled pieces
Average customer review score of 4.3/5 across 2,400+ reviews on Trustpilot as of December 2024
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Quince worth it?
Is Quince jewelry real gold?
How does Quince keep prices so low?
How does Quince compare to Mint & Lily?
Exceptional Value in Fine Jewelry
Quince has carved out a unique position in the affordable jewelry market by offering genuine 14K solid gold pieces under $100 - a feat that seemed impossible just a few years ago. Their commitment to radical transparency sets them apart, with detailed breakdowns of exactly how they achieve these prices through direct-to-consumer sales and efficient supply chain management. While purists might argue that their designs lack creativity, there’s no denying that Quince delivers authentic fine jewelry at accessible price points.
Quality That Exceeds Expectations
The real test of any jewelry brand lies in the quality of their pieces, and Quince consistently delivers solid 14K gold jewelry that holds up to daily wear. Their pieces are properly hallmarked and independently tested, confirming the advertised gold content. However, the brand’s aesthetic philosophy leans heavily toward minimalism - their thin bands, small studs, and simple chains appeal to those seeking timeless basics but may disappoint customers looking for statement pieces or intricate designs. The limited selection is both a strength and weakness, ensuring quality control while restricting choice.