Home › Brands › Mejuri › Charlotte Birthstone Ring
Charlotte Birthstone Ring
Last updated:
82 / 100
ProductScore
Materials: Sterling silver with genuine birthstone; available in 12 stone options
View on Mejuri →The Verdict
Mejuri's Charlotte Birthstone Ring earns a B+ ProductScore of 82/100 — a well-designed personalized ring in sterling silver with genuine gemstones that hits a sweet spot between meaningful and affordable. The silver construction keeps the price accessible while the real stones add legitimate value.
Score Breakdown
What Customers Say
Based on 1,650 mentions across social media and review platforms
The Charlotte Birthstone Ring generates strong gift-related discussion on Reddit and Pinterest. Customers appreciate the genuine gemstones (vs. synthetic) at this price point and the elegant bezel setting. The main critique is the sterling silver tarnishing over time without regular maintenance.
"Got this in garnet for January. The bezel setting protects the stone really well and the silver band is comfortable. Great sub-$100 find."
Reddit r/jewelry
"Bought matching rings for me and my sister with our birthstones. They arrived in beautiful packaging. Mejuri always nails the presentation."
Google Reviews
"The sterling silver has tarnished a bit after 3 months. I use a polishing cloth and it comes right back but it does require maintenance."
Trustpilot
"For $98 you're getting a real gemstone in a well-made setting. Try finding that at a traditional jeweler — you can't."
Reddit r/femalefashionadvice
"The stone is small but sparkly. The bezel setting gives it a modern, clean look rather than the traditional prong style."
Google Reviews
"Wish they had a 14K gold version. I love the design but I don't want to deal with silver tarnishing."
Reddit r/jewelry
Pros & Cons
Strengths
- + Genuine gemstones rather than synthetic stones at a sub-$100 price
- + Protective bezel setting reduces risk of stone damage
- + Sterling silver is a durable precious metal with inherent value
- + 12 birthstone options cover every month
- + Slim band profile makes it an excellent stacking ring
Trade-offs
- − Sterling silver requires periodic polishing to prevent tarnish
- − Not available in gold — limits pairing with gold jewelry collections
- − Gemstones are small (3mm) which reduces visual impact
- − Silver may not suit those who prefer warmer gold tones
Specifications
| Metal | Sterling silver (925) |
| Stone | Genuine birthstone (3mm, bezel-set) |
| Band Width | 1.5mm |
| Sizes | 5–9 (half sizes available) |
| Options | 12 birthstones available |
| Care | Polish with silver cloth regularly; remove before swimming |
Alternatives to Consider
Featured in Gift Guides
Frequently Asked Questions
Are the stones in the Mejuri Charlotte Birthstone Ring real?
Does the Mejuri Charlotte Birthstone Ring tarnish?
What size should I get for the Mejuri Charlotte Birthstone Ring?
Can I wear the Mejuri Charlotte Birthstone Ring every day?
Full Review
Personalized jewelry walks a fine line between meaningful and gimmicky. Mejuri’s Charlotte Birthstone Ring lands firmly on the meaningful side, combining genuine gemstones with a clean modern setting at a price that makes it one of the brand’s most giftable pieces.
Design & Craftsmanship
The bezel setting is the design choice that elevates this ring. Rather than traditional prongs (which can snag and expose the stone to damage), the flush bezel wraps a thin rim of silver around the gemstone, creating a smooth, modern profile that protects the stone during daily wear. It’s a practical and aesthetic win.
The 1.5mm sterling silver band is slim and refined, designed for stacking rather than solo statement wear. The proportions are intentionally delicate — this is a ring that adds a point of interest to a ring stack without dominating it. The 3mm gemstone is modest in size but well-cut, with enough faceting to catch light and display the stone’s natural color.
Value Proposition
At $98, the Charlotte Birthstone Ring delivers genuine value. The combination of sterling silver and a natural (not synthetic) gemstone at this price point is uncommon in the DTC space. Competitors like Studs offer birthstone pieces with synthetic stones at lower prices, while traditional jewelers charge $200+ for comparable natural-stone birthstone rings.
The silver construction is a legitimate cost-saving choice that keeps the ring accessible. The trade-off — periodic polishing to manage tarnish — is minor for most wearers and familiar to anyone who owns silver jewelry.
The Wear Test
Daily wearers report good durability from both the bezel setting and the band. The gemstones are secure and show no looseness even after months of continuous wear. The sterling silver develops a gentle patina that some wearers appreciate as character; those who prefer bright silver find that a quick polish restores the shine completely.
Who Should Buy This
The Charlotte Birthstone Ring is a near-perfect gift for birthdays, graduations, and milestones — personal, quality-made, and accessible at under $100. It’s also a strong self-purchase for stacking enthusiasts who want to add color and meaning to their ring lineup. If you exclusively wear gold, you’ll want to wait for a gold version or look elsewhere.
