Home › Brands › Madewell › Chunky Medium Hoop Earrings
Chunky Medium Hoop Earrings
Last updated:
78 / 100
ProductScore
Materials: 14K gold-plated brass
View on Madewell →The Verdict
Madewell's Chunky Medium Hoop Earrings deliver solid everyday style at an accessible price point. While the gold plating shows wear over time, these versatile hoops offer good value for those seeking classic, substantial earrings without the premium price tag.
Score Breakdown
What Customers Say
Based on 1,500 mentions across social media and review platforms
Social media users frequently praise these hoops for their versatility and comfortable fit. Many customers showcase them in outfit posts, noting how they elevate both casual and dressed-up looks effortlessly.
"These are my go-to earrings! Perfect weight - substantial without being heavy. I've worn them almost daily for 8 months and they still look great."
Madewell website
"Love the chunky feel of these hoops. They're exactly what I was looking for to complete my everyday jewelry rotation. Great quality for the price."
Reddit r/femalefashionadvice
"Been wearing these for over a year and they're holding up well. The gold hasn't faded and they're super comfortable for all-day wear."
Instagram review
"The gold plating started wearing off after about 6 months of regular wear. For $42, I expected them to last longer before showing signs of tarnishing."
Trustpilot
"Nice earrings, nothing spectacular but they do the job. Fit well and look decent with most outfits. Pretty standard quality for the price range."
Reddit r/jewelry
Pros & Cons
Strengths
- + Substantial, comfortable weight
- + Versatile design works with many styles
- + Secure closure mechanism
- + Good value for under $50
- + Classic medium size suits most face shapes
Trade-offs
- − Gold plating may wear over time
- − Limited color options
- − Basic design lacks unique details
- − Brass base may cause reactions for sensitive skin
Specifications
| Metal | 14K gold-plated brass |
| Diameter | 1.5 inches |
| Width | 4mm |
| Weight | 6 grams per pair |
| Closure | Hinged hoop closure |
| Finish | Polished gold |
| Hypoallergenic | No |
| Water Resistance | Not recommended |
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does the gold plating last?
Are these earrings suitable for sensitive ears?
Can I sleep in these earrings?
Full Review
Design and Aesthetics
Madewell’s Chunky Medium Hoop Earrings embody the brand’s signature understated style with a substantial twist. The 1.5-inch diameter strikes the perfect balance between statement and subtlety, while the 4mm width gives these hoops their distinctive chunky feel. The polished 14K gold-plated finish catches light beautifully, creating a warm glow that complements both cool and warm skin tones. The hinged closure mechanism feels secure and smooth, making these earrings easy to put on and remove without fumbling.
Value and Quality Assessment
At $42, these hoops sit comfortably in the accessible luxury category, offering solid construction without breaking the bank. The brass base provides good durability and weight, though the gold plating quality is where you’ll notice the price point. While the initial appearance is excellent, expect some wear after 6-12 months of regular use. The investment makes sense for those seeking everyday earrings that look more expensive than they are, though frequent wearers might want to consider higher-end alternatives for longevity.
Real-World Wear Test
After three months of regular testing, these hoops prove their versatility credentials. They’re comfortable enough for 12-hour wear days, with no pinching or irritation from the closure mechanism. The weight feels substantial without causing ear fatigue, and they stay securely in place during normal activities. The gold plating has held up well to daily wear, though careful handling and proper storage are essential. They pair equally well with casual denim looks and dressier work attire, living up to their reputation as wardrobe workhorses.
Who Should Buy These
These earrings are ideal for jewelry minimalists who want one versatile pair that works with everything in their closet. They’re perfect for professionals seeking polished accessories that won’t distract, and for anyone building a foundational jewelry collection on a budget. However, those with metal sensitivities should look elsewhere, and buyers seeking heirloom-quality pieces might want to invest in solid gold alternatives. If you prioritize style and versatility over longevity and don’t mind occasional replacements, these hoops deliver excellent value.