Home › Brands › James Allen › Gemstone Pendant
Gemstone Pendant
Last updated:
73 / 100
ProductScore
Materials: 14K white, yellow, or rose gold; natural gemstone center (sapphire, ruby, emerald, or other birthstones; approximately 0.50ct)
View on James Allen →The Verdict
James Allen's Gemstone Pendant earns a B- ProductScore of 73/100 — a serviceable colored gemstone pendant with solid precious metal construction and a decent selection of stones to choose from. The same 360-degree viewing technology that makes James Allen great for diamonds is less impactful here, and the pendant itself is competent rather than inspired.
Score Breakdown
What Customers Say
Based on 890 mentions across social media and review platforms
James Allen's gemstone pendants receive less attention than their engagement rings, which is expected given the brand's diamond-focused reputation. Reviews that do exist are generally positive about stone quality and pricing but note that the pendant designs are basic. Several reviewers mention the gemstone selection is good but the settings lack the creativity found at specialty gemstone jewelers.
"Got a sapphire pendant for my wife's birthday. The stone is a beautiful medium blue and the 14K white gold setting is simple and clean. She wears it daily. Good purchase."
Google Reviews
"The pendant is fine but the design is very basic — it's essentially a gemstone in a plain prong setting. Nothing wrong with it, but nothing exciting either."
Reddit r/jewelry
"I appreciated being able to use the 360-degree viewer to examine the exact gemstone I was buying. The sapphire I received matched the online images perfectly."
Google Reviews
"The chain feels thin for a $195 piece. The pendant and stone are nice but I immediately swapped out the included chain for a slightly heavier one."
Trustpilot
"Great value for a real gemstone in real gold. I compared to similar pendants at department stores and independent jewelers — James Allen was the best price for the quality."
Reddit r/femalefashionadvice
Pros & Cons
Strengths
- + Genuine natural gemstones with 360-degree viewing before purchase
- + Solid 14K gold construction provides durability and lasting value
- + Wide selection of gemstone types covers all birthstone months
- + Competitive pricing for genuine precious gemstone jewelry
- + Free shipping and 30-day return policy minimize purchase risk
Trade-offs
- − Setting design is basic and lacks creative distinction
- − Included chain feels thin and may benefit from replacement
- − James Allen's gemstone expertise and reputation trails their diamond specialization
- − Limited pendant design options compared to dedicated gemstone jewelers
Specifications
| Center Stone | Natural gemstone, approximately 0.50ct (varies by stone type) |
| Metal | 14K gold (white, yellow, or rose) |
| Setting | Four-prong basket |
| Chain | 14K gold cable chain, 18 inches |
| Closure | Spring ring clasp |
| Returns | 30-day free returns |
Frequently Asked Questions
Are James Allen gemstones real?
What gemstones are available in the James Allen pendant?
How does James Allen's gemstone pricing compare to other jewelers?
Can you customize the James Allen Gemstone Pendant setting?
Full Review
James Allen built its reputation on diamonds, and that specialization shows when they venture into colored gemstone territory. The Gemstone Pendant is a perfectly adequate fine jewelry piece — solid materials, fair pricing, clean construction — but it lacks the distinctive edge that makes their diamond offerings stand out.
The Stone Selection
James Allen’s gemstone inventory is respectable, covering all major birthstones and popular colored gems. The 360-degree viewing technology, which is revolutionary for diamond shopping, works here too — you can examine the exact gemstone you’ll receive from every angle. For colored stones, this is particularly useful because color and inclusions vary significantly between individual gems.
The sapphires tend to be the strongest offerings, with good medium-blue saturation. Rubies and emeralds are more variable in quality, which is typical of these notoriously challenging stone types.
Design Limitations
This is where the Gemstone Pendant falls short of its potential. The four-prong basket setting is functional but uninspired — it’s the default jewelry design equivalent of a white wall. The gemstone does all the visual work while the setting simply holds it in place. Compare this to specialty gemstone jewelers who design settings that enhance and frame the stone’s unique characteristics, and the difference becomes apparent.
The included 14K gold chain is similarly basic. It’s genuine gold and adequately constructed, but it feels thin relative to the pendant and the price point. Several reviewers report upgrading to a slightly heavier chain for a more substantial feel.
Value Assessment
At $195 for a genuine gemstone in solid 14K gold, the pricing is fair and competitive. You’re getting real materials at a price that undercuts traditional jewelers by a meaningful margin. The 30-day return policy and free shipping further reduce the risk of buying gemstone jewelry online.
Who Should Buy This
The James Allen Gemstone Pendant is a solid choice for buyers who want a genuine, well-priced gemstone pendant without overthinking the design. It’s particularly good as a birthstone gift — the stone quality is there, the materials are genuine, and the price is right. For buyers who care deeply about pendant design and craftsmanship, consider specialty gemstone jewelers with more creative settings.
