Home › Brands › James Allen › Classic Six-Prong Solitaire
Classic Six-Prong Solitaire
Last updated:
78 / 100
ProductScore
Materials: 14K or 18K white, yellow, or rose gold; 6-prong setting for center diamond (diamond sold separately)
View on James Allen →The Verdict
James Allen's Classic Six-Prong Solitaire earns a B ProductScore of 78/100 — the quintessential engagement ring setting executed with solid craftsmanship and backed by the best diamond visualization technology in the industry. The 360-degree diamond viewer is genuinely game-changing for online buyers, though the ring setting itself is competent rather than exceptional.
Score Breakdown
What Customers Say
Based on 4,800 mentions across social media and review platforms
James Allen's solitaire settings dominate Reddit engagement ring discussions, largely because of the brand's 360-degree diamond viewing technology. Reviewers consistently praise the ability to examine diamonds in extreme detail before purchasing. The settings themselves receive moderate praise — solid quality but not exceptional. Some reviewers note the prongs can appear slightly thick compared to premium jeweler settings.
"The 360-degree diamond viewer is what sold me. Being able to spin and zoom into the actual diamond I was buying from my couch gave me more confidence than any in-store experience."
Reddit r/engagementrings
"Good setting but not amazing. The prongs are a bit thicker than what I've seen at local jewelers. It holds the diamond securely but doesn't disappear the way really refined settings do."
Reddit r/jewelry
"Ordered a 1ct round in this setting and it arrived exactly as it looked online. No surprises. The ring is classic, well-made, and my fiancée is thrilled."
Google Reviews
"Customer service was excellent during the buying process but slower for my resize request afterward. Took about 3 weeks. The ring itself is great though."
Trustpilot
"I compared James Allen settings to Blue Nile and Brilliant Earth side by side. James Allen's pricing was slightly lower and the diamond selection was larger. Setting quality was comparable across all three."
Reddit r/engagementrings
"Perfect classic engagement ring. Nothing flashy, nothing unexpected — and that's exactly what I wanted. The six-prong holds the diamond beautifully and securely."
Google Reviews
Pros & Cons
Strengths
- + Industry-leading 360-degree diamond viewer lets you inspect every stone before buying
- + Competitive pricing on settings, typically 10-15% below comparable traditional jewelers
- + Six-prong design provides excellent diamond security while maximizing light exposure
- + Available in multiple metal types and karats for full customization
- + Free resizing and 30-day return policy reduce online buying risk
Trade-offs
- − Prongs are slightly thicker than premium jeweler settings, partially obscuring the diamond
- − Setting quality is solid but not exceptional — competent rather than artisanal
- − Post-purchase customer service can be slower than the attentive pre-sale experience
- − Setting is sold separately from the diamond, so total cost can escalate quickly
Specifications
| Metal Options | 14K or 18K gold (white, yellow, or rose); platinum available |
| Prong Style | Six-prong solitaire (rounded prongs) |
| Band Width | 2.0mm |
| Compatible Shapes | Round brilliant (0.50ct–3.00ct) |
| Sizes | 3–13 (half sizes available) |
| Warranty | Lifetime manufacturing warranty; free prong tightening |
Featured in Gift Guides
Frequently Asked Questions
Does James Allen's Classic Six-Prong include the diamond?
How does James Allen's diamond viewer compare to seeing diamonds in person?
Is a six-prong solitaire better than four-prong?
Can you return a James Allen engagement ring?
Full Review
The six-prong solitaire is the most iconic engagement ring silhouette in existence, and James Allen’s version executes the fundamentals with quiet competence. What elevates this particular offering above a generic solitaire isn’t the setting itself — it’s the revolutionary buying experience that surrounds it.
The James Allen Difference: Technology
James Allen’s 360-degree Super Zoom diamond viewer is genuinely transformative for online diamond buying. Every diamond in their inventory is photographed in extreme detail, allowing buyers to spin, zoom, and examine each stone from every angle at 20x magnification. This isn’t a gimmick — it’s the most powerful tool available for remote diamond evaluation, and it changes the calculus of buying an engagement ring online.
The ability to identify inclusions, evaluate cut quality, and compare color grades from your couch gives buyers a level of transparency that even in-store shopping often can’t match. For the Classic Six-Prong Solitaire, this means you can pair the setting with exactly the diamond you want, evaluated to your satisfaction.
The Setting Itself
The six-prong setting is well-made but not remarkable. The prongs are slightly thicker than what you’d find at a premium independent jeweler — functional and secure, but lacking the knife-edge refinement that makes high-end settings seem to disappear. The band is a standard 2.0mm width in your choice of gold or platinum, with a smooth, comfortable interior.
This is a setting that does its job reliably: hold the diamond securely, allow maximum light entry, and stay out of the way visually. It doesn’t aspire to be anything more, and there’s something respectable about that straightforwardness.
Buying Experience & Value
James Allen’s pricing is consistently competitive — typically 10-15% below comparable settings at Tiffany or independent jewelers for equivalent specifications. The free resizing, 30-day return policy, and lifetime warranty provide meaningful peace of mind for what is, for most buyers, a significant financial commitment.
Who Should Buy This
The Classic Six-Prong Solitaire is ideal for buyers who want a timeless, no-surprises engagement ring setting and want to leverage James Allen’s best-in-class diamond selection technology. If you want the most traditional ring possible with the most modern buying experience, this is your play.
