Gorjana Review
Last updated: · 38 reviews analyzed
The Verdict
Gorjana delivers solid everyday jewelry at accessible prices, but quality can be inconsistent with some users reporting clasp breaks and tarnishing within months. The brand excels at California-style layering pieces under $80, though customer service experiences vary widely from 'amazing' to unresponsive.
The Social Verdict
Based on analysis of 38+ reviews across Reddit, Trustpilot, Google Reviews, Exa Web Search
Customer sentiment is polarized, with users praising Gorjana's affordable layering jewelry and California aesthetic while criticizing quality control issues. Many reviewers love the brand for daily wear pieces under $80, but concerns about durability and inconsistent customer service create mixed experiences. The brand maintains strong social media presence but faces recurring complaints about clasps breaking and pieces tarnishing sooner than expected.
"I would first like to say Gorjana has AMAZING customer service. Prompt, happy to help and go out of their way to satisfy their customers. However, the quality of my fine jewelry purchased through them was poor."
— Trustpilot
"This bracelet broke as soon as my daughter put it on. Very poor quality."
— Gorjana Reviews
"Perfect as a layering piece with my set! I've only had it a week, but I have yet to take it off. Shower, workouts, and customer service was also fantastic."
— Gorjana Reviews
"The clasp on my fine jewelry bracelet broke after only purchasing it less than 3 months ago. When I reached out to customer service they did not even respond."
— RatingFacts
Pros & Cons
Strengths
- + Accessible pricing with most pieces under $80
- + Strong California-inspired aesthetic perfect for layering
- + Wide variety of styles from dainty to statement pieces
- + Anti-tarnish barrier on gold-plated jewelry
Trade-offs
- − Inconsistent quality control with frequent clasp breakage reports
- − Customer service experiences vary dramatically from excellent to unresponsive
- − Thin gold plating can tarnish despite anti-tarnish claims
Product Reviews
5 products reviewed
Heart Padlock Necklace
Necklaces · 18K gold plated brass
Gorjana's Heart Padlock Necklace earns a B ProductScore of 78/100 — a playful take on the padlock jewelry trend with a heart-shaped twist that reads as romantic without being saccharine. The 3D construction and heft give it a premium feel, though the brass base at $75 continues Gorjana's pattern of brand-premium pricing.
Lou Tag Necklace
Necklaces · 18K gold plated brass
Gorjana's Lou Tag Necklace earns a B ProductScore of 78/100 — a clean, minimalist dog-tag-style pendant that works well for custom engraving and everyday wear. The design is versatile and gender-neutral, though the brass-based construction at $58 remains a value concern when sterling silver options exist nearby.
Parker Initial Necklace
Necklaces · 18K gold plated brass
Gorjana's Parker Initial Necklace earns a B ProductScore of 76/100 — a pretty initial pendant with clean design and decent quality, but at $60 for gold-plated brass it faces stiff competition from brands offering sterling silver at similar prices. The coin-style pendant is distinctive, though the plating longevity leaves something to be desired.
Power Gemstone Bracelet
Bracelets · Genuine gemstone beads (varies by stone)
Gorjana's Power Gemstone Bracelet earns a B ProductScore of 75/100 — a photogenic crystal bead bracelet that leans into the wellness-jewelry trend with style and decent execution. The genuine gemstone beads and gold-plated accent bar look great, though the healing crystal positioning may not resonate with all buyers and the elastic durability is a known concern.
Venice Layering Set
Necklaces · 18K gold plated brass
Gorjana's Venice Layering Set earns a B- ProductScore of 72/100 — a pre-styled three-necklace set that takes the guesswork out of necklace stacking. The curated lengths and complementary styles create an effortlessly polished look, but at $130 for three brass-based necklaces, the per-piece value is a real concern.
Key Data Points
Gorjana maintains a 2.3/5 TrustScore on Trustpilot based on 36 reviews, with quality issues being the most frequently cited complaint
Analysis of 302+ product reviews shows an average 4.7/5 rating on individual items, indicating satisfaction varies significantly by specific product
Multiple review sources confirm clasp breakage within 3 months as a recurring quality issue across different product lines
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Gorjana worth it?
Does Gorjana jewelry tarnish?
How is Gorjana's customer service?
How does Gorjana compare to Mint & Lily?
Gorjana occupies an interesting position in the market: strong design sensibility and genuine style leadership, but at a price point that customer data suggests is a bit high for the materials delivered. The B+ is earned — this is good jewelry from a reputable brand — but the gap between Gorjana’s style and value scores tells the real story.
If you’re buying Gorjana, you’re buying the design language and the layering ecosystem. Customers who love the brand really love it, and the pieces do work beautifully together. But if you’re comparing purely on quality-per-dollar, the data points to better options in the same tier.