All Brand Ratings

Harry Winston is the King of Diamonds, representing the absolute pinnacle of gemstone quality and high jewelry craftsmanship. Specializing in investment-grade diamonds and rare colored gemstones, Winston creates pieces that are as much museum-worthy treasures as they are wearable jewelry.

Graff is the undisputed king of extraordinary diamonds, handling the world's most significant stones with unparalleled expertise. A London-based house where every piece is a masterclass in sourcing, cutting, and setting the rarest gems on earth.

Van Cleef & Arpels is the epitome of poetic, nature-inspired high jewelry, renowned for the iconic Alhambra clover motif and extraordinary savoir-faire. With techniques like the Mystery Set perfected over a century, VCA creates wearable art that commands fervent collector loyalty and exceptional secondary market premiums.

Buccellati is the undisputed master of metalwork in high jewelry, famous for their Rigato engraving technique that transforms gold into surfaces resembling delicate silk or lace. An Italian house where old-world artisanship reigns supreme.

Cartier is the Jeweler of Kings and the king of jewelers, defining luxury jewelry for over 175 years. Iconic collections like Love, Juste un Clou, and Panthère combine flawless craftsmanship with unmistakable design heritage that commands global recognition and exceptional resale value.

Mint & Lily earns an A rating with a JewelryScore of 93/100, driven by exceptional quality scores and strong value in the under-$100 personalized jewelry segment. The brand delivers consistently on its core promise of durable, beautifully crafted name necklaces and personalized pieces.

Boucheron is the avant-garde rebel of Place Vendôme, blending unconventional materials like rock crystal, wood, and ceramic with traditional high jewelry techniques. The house behind the iconic Quatre ring and breathtaking animal-inspired creations.

Bulgari brings unmistakable Italian boldness to luxury jewelry, defined by voluptuous gold work, vibrant colored gemstones, and the iconic Serpenti serpent motif. Where French houses favor delicacy, Bulgari celebrates drama — delivering statement pieces with exceptional Roman craftsmanship.

Tiffany & Co. is an American jewelry institution synonymous with the iconic Blue Box and world-class diamond settings. Spanning a wide price range from accessible silver pieces to six-figure high jewelry, Tiffany delivers exceptional gemstone quality and timeless designs backed by nearly two centuries of heritage.

Chopard masterfully merges Swiss watchmaking precision with joyful, playful jewelry design, epitomized by the iconic Happy Diamonds collection. A family-owned house committed to ethical luxury with Fairmined gold and responsibly sourced stones.

Monica Vinader delivers exceptional quality with gold vermeil that maintains its appearance even after 2+ years of daily wear, backed by an industry-leading 5-year warranty. While premium-priced for contemporary jewelry, the combination of durability, customer service excellence, and royal endorsements justifies the investment for those seeking everyday luxury pieces.

Automic Gold delivers exceptional quality solid 14k gold jewelry with outstanding customer service and inclusivity, though pieces can be very delicate and shipping times often exceed estimates. The brand excels in minimalist designs with genuine sustainability credentials, making it worth the investment for those seeking ethically-made fine jewelry.

Messika has redefined modern diamond jewelry with a sleek, edgy Parisian aesthetic that makes diamonds feel cool rather than conventional. Founded in 2005 by Valérie Messika, the house brings a fashion-forward energy to high jewelry.

Foundrae creates deeply symbolic 18K gold jewelry where every motif carries ancient meaning, from strength to resilience to karma. Their medallions and charms have become modern talismans for a discerning clientele who want jewelry with philosophical weight behind it.

Mejuri delivers on its promise of everyday fine jewelry with 14k gold pieces that maintain quality over years of wear, though gold vermeil options show tarnishing issues. At $38-$500, it offers accessible luxury with exceptional craftsmanship, making it worth the investment for minimalist jewelry lovers.

David Yurman stands as a luxury jewelry powerhouse renowned for its iconic Cable motif and exceptional craftsmanship. While prices are premium, the brand delivers genuine luxury quality with timeless designs that justify the investment.

Dana Rebecca Designs is a go-to for delicate diamond jewelry that sparkles without feeling overdone. The brand excels at creating everyday luxury pieces in 14K gold with genuine diamonds and colored gemstones that punch above their weight.

Monica Rich Kosann is the undisputed queen of the modern locket, crafting heirloom-quality pieces in 18K gold and sterling silver that carry deep personal meaning. Her charm necklaces and lockets blend vintage soul with contemporary refinement, making each piece a vessel for memories.

Canada's premier luxury jeweler delivers exceptional craftsmanship and heritage design but commands premium prices. Strong brand legacy with distinctive Canadian identity appeals to discerning buyers seeking timeless elegance.

Shy Creation delivers exquisite diamond pavé fine jewelry with a glamorous edge, specializing in intricate settings that maximize sparkle. Their 14K gold pieces strike a balance between luxury craftsmanship and accessible pricing within the fine jewelry category.

Aurate delivers solid 14K and 18K gold jewelry with ethical sourcing at fair prices, though their design range can feel limited. The brand excels in quality construction and transparency but lacks the style innovation of some competitors.

Brilliant Earth delivers solid quality and exceptional ethical sourcing with a premium price tag. While customers praise the craftsmanship and customization options, the 15-20% price premium over competitors and mixed post-sale service experiences make it best suited for ethics-conscious buyers willing to pay extra for responsible sourcing.

Blue Nile stands as a trusted online jewelry pioneer, offering excellent value on GIA-certified diamonds and classic fine jewelry pieces. While their designs lean conservative and lack the prestige of luxury heritage brands, their transparent pricing and quality certifications make them a solid mid-tier choice.

Jenny Bird delivers distinctive sculptural jewelry with bold architectural designs that stand out from typical fashion jewelry. While pieces are well-made for the price point, the heavy gold plating can show wear over time with frequent use.

Missoma delivers on style and customer service excellence but has notable durability issues for its price point. While the brand offers exceptional customer support with quick replacements and maintains strong celebrity appeal, multiple reviews cite tarnishing within 3 months and jewelry breaking after limited wear, making it better suited for occasional rather than daily wear.

Vrai stands out in the lab-grown diamond space with genuine zero-emission credentials and quality 14K gold settings. While prices run higher than traditional fashion jewelry brands, the brand delivers on its sustainability promise with DERA-certified diamonds and solid craftsmanship.

The Pearl Source offers excellent quality pearls at competitive prices by cutting out retail markups, though their design aesthetic leans traditional. Their direct-from-farm sourcing provides exceptional value for Akoya and Tahitian pearls, making them ideal for classic pearl jewelry enthusiasts.

Anabel Aram creates stunning nature-inspired sculptural jewelry that transforms botanical and organic forms into wearable art. The brand offers remarkable design creativity at accessible price points using gold-plated sterling silver with pearl and crystal accents.

Lizzie Fortunato creates bold, art-inspired statement jewelry using semi-precious stones and artisanal techniques. The brand is a favorite among fashion insiders for its oversized necklaces and vibrant color palettes that blur the line between jewelry and wearable art.

Argento Vivo delivers solid sterling silver basics at accessible prices, excelling in classic hoops and chains. While the designs lean conservative and gold plating can wear over time, the brand offers reliable quality for everyday staples.

En Route delivers charming vintage-inspired pieces that resonate with the It-girl aesthetic at accessible price points. While quality is decent for the price range, longevity concerns with gold plating may affect long-term value.

James Allen excels at online diamond shopping with industry-leading 360° visualization technology and strong customer service, but quality control issues with settings cause durability problems within the first year. Best for buyers who prioritize selection and transparency over long-term craftsmanship.

Linjer delivers on its promise of minimalist, Scandinavian-inspired jewelry with solid materials at reasonable prices. While the designs may feel too simple for some, the brand excels at timeless pieces that justify their mid-tier pricing.

Madewell delivers solid demi-fine jewelry that successfully bridges costume and fine jewelry with reliable quality and timeless designs. While prices have crept up and selection is limited, their pieces offer excellent durability for the price point.

Quince delivers exceptional value with genuine 14K gold pieces under $100, backed by impressive supply chain transparency. While their minimalist aesthetic won't appeal to everyone, the quality-to-price ratio is outstanding for solid gold jewelry.

Pavoi delivers impressive quality and durability for budget-friendly jewelry, making it a standout choice for everyday gold-plated pieces. While style options can be basic, the brand's focus on well-made fundamentals at accessible prices has earned it a loyal following.

Soko delivers on its ethical promise with beautiful handcrafted pieces from Kenyan artisans, though quality can be inconsistent and prices feel high for brass jewelry. The brand excels in meaningful impact and unique designs but may disappoint those expecting luxury-grade finishing.

Studs delivers affordable, trendy earrings averaging $40 with good initial quality and comfortable wear, but faces notable durability issues with tarnishing occurring within 6-12 months of daily wear. The brand excels at social media presence and piercing services but struggles with inconsistent customer service and long-term jewelry performance.

Gorjana delivers solid everyday jewelry at accessible prices, but quality can be inconsistent with some users reporting clasp breaks and tarnishing within months. The brand excels at California-style layering pieces under $80, though customer service experiences vary widely from 'amazing' to unresponsive.

Ettika delivers solid bohemian-inspired jewelry with crystal accents and layering sets at accessible prices. While quality is decent for the price point, some pieces show wear over time, making it best for trend-conscious shoppers seeking statement pieces under $90.

BaubleBar delivers trendy, affordable jewelry with exceptional customer service, but quality is inconsistent - higher-end pieces (18k gold) hold up well while lower-tier items frequently tarnish within days to weeks. Best for fashion-forward shoppers who prioritize style over longevity and appreciate responsive support when issues arise.

Ana Luisa offers well-designed, trendy jewelry with good customer service and sustainable practices, but quality consistency issues and deceptive membership enrollment practices significantly impact the overall experience. While many pieces hold up well for everyday wear, tarnishing complaints and the controversial AL Luxe membership create legitimate concerns for potential buyers.

Catbird offers beautifully delicate 14k gold jewelry that's beloved by celebrities, but suffers from inconsistent quality control and poor customer service that significantly impacts the overall experience. While the solid gold construction prevents tarnishing, numerous reports of defective pieces and shipping issues make it a risky investment despite the aesthetic appeal.

Pandora offers emotionally appealing jewelry with strong brand recognition, but suffers from significant quality inconsistencies including frequent tarnishing, broken clasps, and gems falling out. While the customizable charm system has sentimental value, the poor customer service and quality issues relative to the $30-$400 price range make it difficult to recommend.

Swarovski offers stunning crystal brilliance and premium aesthetic appeal but falls short on durability and value. With widespread tarnishing issues within 1-2 years and frequent crystal loss, it's best viewed as fashion jewelry for special occasions rather than everyday wear.

Kendra Scott jewelry consistently fails to deliver quality matching its $50-200 price point, with widespread reports of tarnishing within weeks, plating wearing off, and pieces turning skin green. While the brand offers trendy designs and customization options, the poor durability and customer service issues make it difficult to recommend.