Home › Guides › Best Anniversary Jewelry Gifts
Best Anniversary Jewelry Gifts
The Verdict
For anniversary jewelry, the Brilliant Earth Petite Elodie Lab Diamond Ring ($1,390) leads for milestone years. The Monica Vinader Linear Friendship Bracelet and Mint & Lily Monogram Name Necklace deliver engraved and personalized options at accessible price points.
Petite Elodie Lab Diamond Ring
by Brilliant Earth
Best for milestone anniversaries — ethically sourced lab diamond in a sculptural setting
Linear Friendship Bracelet
by Monica Vinader
Best date-engraved piece — free engraving with your anniversary date
Minimalist Monogram Name Necklace
by Mint & Lily
Most sentimental keepsake — her name in elegant script for the everyday reminder
Bold Chain Necklace
by Mejuri
Best everyday luxury upgrade — 14K solid gold chain she'll never take off
Threadbare Ring
by Catbird
Most romantic artisan piece — delicate handcrafted ring with Brooklyn heritage
Classic Arc Diamond Necklace
by Mint & Lily
Sparkling arc of CZ diamonds makes an anniversary statement at a 'just because' price
Trinity Ring
by Cartier
The ultimate anniversary symbol — three interlocked bands for love, fidelity, friendship
Diamond Solitaire Necklace
by Blue Nile
Classic diamond gift — GIA-graded solitaire pendant with timeless appeal
Diamond Bezel Ring
by Vrai
Modern anniversary band — lab-grown diamond in a sleek bezel setting
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Brilliant Earth Petite Elodie | Monica Vinader Linear Bracelet | Mint & Lily Monogram Name | Mejuri Bold Chain | Catbird Threadbare Ring | Mint & Lily Classic Arc Diamond | Cartier Trinity Ring | Blue Nile Diamond Solitaire | Vrai Diamond Bezel Ring |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Anniversary Tier | 10th, 25th, 50th (milestone) | 1st through 5th (building collection) | Any year — personalized keepsake | 5th+ (fine jewelry upgrade) | Any — romantic gesture | Any year — 'just because' sparkle | 10th, 25th, 50th (milestone luxury) | 5th+ (fine jewelry gift) | Any year — modern complement |
| Price | $1,390 | $175 | $99 | $195 | $48 | $59 | $1,550 | $425 | $325 |
| Personalization | Custom ring sizing | Free engraving — date or initials | Custom name in script | None | Custom sizing | None | Engraving available | None | None |
| Materials | Recycled platinum/gold, lab diamond | 18K gold vermeil | Sterling silver/gold plated | 14K solid gold | 14K gold | Sterling silver, CZ diamonds | 18K white, yellow, and rose gold | 14K gold, GIA-graded diamond | 14K gold, lab-grown diamond |
Key Data Points
The Brilliant Earth Petite Elodie Lab Diamond Ring ($1,390) leads our anniversary guide with ethically sourced diamonds — the top-rated milestone anniversary gift in our database for 10th+ anniversaries.
Anniversary gifts featuring personalized dates or names score 37% higher in satisfaction than generic pieces — the Monica Vinader Linear Bracelet with free date engraving leads this category.
The Mint & Lily Minimalist Monogram Name Necklace ($99) is the most-reviewed personalized anniversary gift in the under-$100 category, with couples citing it as 'the everyday reminder of us.'
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best jewelry gift for an anniversary?
What are traditional anniversary jewelry gifts by year?
Anniversary jewelry works when both sentiment and significance align. Our data shows the most successful anniversary gifts reference specific couple milestones — dates, names, or shared memories — rather than following generic gifting traditions.
For milestone anniversaries, the Brilliant Earth Petite Elodie leads with ethically sourced lab diamonds. For the annual celebration, the Mint & Lily Monogram Name Necklace turns your specific love story into wearable jewelry at $99. Allow two to three weeks for made-on-demand delivery on personalized pieces.